

|
NEEDS AND BENEFITS OF RENEWABLE ENERGY TECHNOLOGIES
Quotes
"Global warming is no longer a theory. Since the 1970s, the world has warmed by about 0.15oC per decade, and 1998 was the warmest year on record. In England, four of the five warmest years in the 340-year record occurred in the last decade. These are startling statistics. The clear message from the scientific community is that this warming is due, at least in part, to the increasing concentrations of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere." - Department of Environment, Transport and the Regions, 1999
"Everyone can part a part in increasing the amount of renewable energy the UK uses. Educating people is the key to helping people develop their own renewable energy ideas. I am determined to no longer waste the will and determination of local groups to produce green electricity" - Brian Wilson, Minister for Energy
"Renewable energy - biomass, wind, solar or whatever - is local. It simply can’t be put somewhere else." - Rt Hon M Meacher, Minister for the Environment, 2000
Need for Renewable Energy 
Climate change and global warming are undeniable challenges facing the international community, and both nations and individuals need to act to as part of the solution. One of most challenging dilemmas facing us as we move into the 21st Century is how to address and overcome the issues of climate change and global warming. The Inter-Governmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) found that:
"if we continue as we are, global mean temperature would increase by 0.3% per decade (within a range of 0.2 to 0.4 degrees); this is greater than the world has ever seen over the past 10,000 years. Global mean temperature over the next century would become higher than at any time over the last 150,000 years; sea level would rise by 6cm per decade (within a range of 3-10cm per decade) over the next century, 3 to 6 times the rate seen over the last 100 years".
The Department of Environment, Transport and the Regions has re-emphasised these concerns in a recent publication concerning climate change where it states that:
"Global warming is no longer a theory. Since the 1970s, the world has warmed by about 0.15oC per decade, and 1998 was the warmest year on record. In England, four of the five warmest years in the 340-year record occurred in the last decade. These are startling statistics. The clear message from the scientific community is that this warming is due, at least in part, to the increasing concentrations of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere."
On 21 January 2001, the IPCC issued a Summary for Policymakers which describes the current state of understanding of the climate system and provides estimates of its projected future evolution and their uncertainties. This report indicates that the average global surface temperature is projected to increase by 1.4 to 5.8OC, between 0.4 and 2.3OC higher than previously predicted. Whilst there has been substantial debate about the cause of climate changes that have occurred during the last part of the 20th Century, more refined modelling techniques confirm that recent climate changes, especially over the last few decades, are almost entirely caused by human activity, particularly in the emission of long-lived greenhouse gases such as CO2 arising from the burning of fossil fuels.
The English Nature report "SSSI’s in England at risk from acid rain" (Biset and Framer, English Nature report No. 15, 1993) considered the impact of sulphur deposition on SSSI’s in England and concluded that:
..."even if the EC Large Combustion Plant Directive were to be implemented in full, 600 SSSI’s were at risk from continued acidification".
These sites represented 26% of the total land area designated SSSI in 1993
Hence the environmental challenge posed by the production of greenhouse gases led to an international response, which was first initiated by the World Commission on Environment and Development meeting in 1983, and subsequently addressed at the Earth Summit 1992. Several Conventions arose from these meetings, including the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change and more recently the Kyoto Protocol. The UK response has been to introduce policies and legislation to address global warming and provide mechanisms for the introduction and enforcement of international conventions to which it is a signatory.
Renewable energy generation is now posited as a solution to global warming as it does not, generally, lead to the creation of greenhouse gases. Forms of renewable energy, such as wind, hydro, biomass and solar, are clean technologies that are encouraged to combat global warming. In Europe, guidance on promoting green energy and combating global warming is found in the European Commission’s Green Paper. In the UK, any proposals for the development of RE have to accord with the planning system. Therefore specific guidance on planning for such developments has been prepared. This guidance is contained in Planning Policy Guidance 22 (PPG22) for England, Planning Guidance Wales, and National Planning Policy Guidance 6 (NPPG6) for Scotland. This guidance is further supplemented in more detail for Wales in Technical Advice Note 8 (TAN8) and by Planning Advice Note 45 (PAN45) in Scotland.
Benefits of RE generation
The benefits of RE generation are not just limited to the environmental benefits to be gained from the reduction in green house gases. There are other significant benefits:
Employment
The renewable energy industry is becoming a significant employer in many fields of work, from the design and manufacturing of machinery and equipment, through to environmental consultants carrying out field studies and planners looking for suitable locations. The European Commission Directorate of Energy study on wind employment benefits estimated that the wind industry in 2001 provided more than 50,000 jobs worldwide. This figure accounts for both direct and indirect employment. By indirect employment we mean the people who are employed manufacturing components for wind turbines, and the people who are involved in installing wind turbines worldwide.
Economics
While electricity costs from renewable energy sources have dropped significantly over the past 25 years, these costs are still greater than wholesale electricity prices. However, there is growing evidence for environmental damage caused by fossil fuel sources as discussed above and the environmental costs of fossil fuel burning, though difficult to quantify, would likely result in greater overall costs created by non-RE generation.
Life cycle emissions
Exploiting renewable energy as a resource shows substantial advantages over conventional electricity generation technologies in the reduced life cycle emissions of carbon dioxide. These are shown in the table below:
Life Cycle Carbon Dioxide Emissions from Renewable Energy and Fossil Fuels, ETSU 1999
|
| Technology |
| CO2, g/kWh |
| Onshore wind |
| 9 |
| Poultry litter |
| 10 |
| Straw |
| 13 |
| Animal slarry digestion |
| 31 |
| Landfill Gas* |
| 19 |
| Solar (Photovoltaics, new houses) |
| 178 |
| Municipal incineration |
| 364 |
| Gas-fired combined cycle |
| 446 |
| Coal best practice |
| 955 |
| Average UK generating mix |
| 654 |
* CO2 emissions only. Landfill methane and other greenhouse gases were not considered.
Life Cycle Carbon Dioxide Emissions from Renewable Energy and Fossil Fuels, ETSU 1999
Energy contribution
The contribution of renewable energy schemes to the overall energy generation for the UK is still small - around 2.8% in 1999. Largely this small contribution comes through hydro-electric generation (around 1.5% of the total generation), biomass (around 1.1%) and wind (0.2%). Under the Renewables Obligation, however, the government is aiming to encourage the generation of 10% of the UK’s energy needs by 2010 through a mixture of the different RE technologies. Some reports indicate that as much as three times our present energy demand could be met by offshore wind projects alone but this is unlikely to be feasible without greater financial, policy and planning incentives.
Energy Conversion
|
| 1000 Wh |
| = |
| 1Kwh |
| 1000 kWh |
| = |
| 1MWh |
| 1000 MWh |
| = |
| 1GWh |
| 1000 GWh |
| = |
| 1TWh |
|
| 1000 W |
| = |
| 1kW |
| 1000 kW |
| = |
| 1MW |
| 1000 MW |
| = |
| 1GW |
| 1000 GW |
| = |
| 1TW |
To translate between kW, MW , GW - kWh, MWh, GWh
To calculate/estimated electricity generation is as follows:
For existing capacity multiply:
|
| Capacity in MW |
| Load Factor |
| 8760 |
|
| To account for intermittence |
| No of hours in the year |
For potential capacity multiply:
|
| Capacity in MW |
| Build Factor |
| Load Factor |
| 8760 |
|
| To account for non build projects |
| To account for intermittence |
| No of hours in the year |
This gives MWh.
The absolute latest build and load factors ETSU are using are as follows:
|
| Technology |
| Build/Capacity Factor |
| Load Factor |
| Landfill Gas |
| 1.0 |
| 0.7 |
| Energy from Waste |
| 0.4 |
| 0.9 |
| EfW with CHP |
| 0.5 |
| 0.9 |
| Small hydro |
| 0.96 |
| 0.4 |
| Large Wind |
| 0.36 |
| 0.63 |
| Small Wind |
| 0.57 |
| 0.5 |
| Agricultural Waste |
| 0.81 |
| 0.9 |
| Energy Crops |
| 0.42 |
| 0.9 |
For Example, consider a wind-farm of 100MW
|
| 1. Capacity stated as |
| 100 MW |
| |
| 2. Multiply by no of hrs in yr |
| 8,760 |
| 876,000 |
| 3. Multiply by the availability factor (to account for maintenance) |
| 98% |
| 858,480 |
| 4. Multiply by the load factor (to account for intermittency) |
| 43% |
| 369,146 |
| 5. Expected MWh produced |
| |
| 369,146 MWh |
Environmental Benefits
The generation of energy from renewable sources avoids the emissions from traditional fossil fuel burning technologies. These emissions include carbon dioxide, a green house gas, nitrogen oxides and sulphur dioxides. These latter gases are pollutants causing acid rain and ozone depletion. It is possible to estimate, through RE generation, what quantities of each are avoided. A simple Environmental Spreadsheet can be used to do this.
Local economic and social benefits
Local economic and social benefits can be summarised as follows:
Local and regional employment during the construction of the RE projects
Significant construction contracts awarded to local or regional companies
Further long term employment possibilities through the requirement for ongoing operational management and/or maintenance of equipment etc.
Other benefits to local businesses from ongoing requirements for goods and services
The provision of a reliable income stream for landowners upon whose property the RE project may be based
An educational resource for local schools and community groups
An additional tourist attraction
An overall contribution towards local sustainability
Public Attitudes
Due to the controversy often surrounding renewable energy projects, a whole host of public attitude surveys have been conducted to gauge the true feelings of the public. In a recent RSPB survey conducted between September and October 2001 in which 1000 adults were canvassed, questions were asked regarding what forms of energy generation should be built over the next 10 years in the UK. 52% of those asked supported wind on land, 47% supported wind at sea, and 44% supported solar power, as opposed to only 8% who supported nuclear, 5% who supported coal, and 17% who supported gas fired power stations. In the same survey 68%believed nuclear and 38% believed coal should not be built. Further information on public attitudes can be found in the following:
Public attitudes survey for wind farms in Scotland: Scottish Wind Farms
The British Wind Energy Association guide to Public Attitude Surveys
Since 1990 thirteen different research studies have been carried out by different research groups (12 of which were independent bodies) in to public attitudes towards wind power. The surveys consulted 3,549 people, the majority of whom lived close to a site or a proposed site. The surveys showed that the overwhelming majority of the residents, in areas with a wind farm, are in favour of wind power, both in theory as a renewable energy source and in their area. Across all of the surveys undertaken 80% of people supported their local wind farm. Respondents who lived near a site and had direct experience of a wind farm were more positive than those who did not have a wind farm near them . The findings of these surveys are summarised in Table 5.1
Summary of Independent Public Opinion Surveys - January 1998
|
| Wind farm |
| Commissioned by |
| Date |
| In favour of wind energy |
| Against wind energy |
| Undecided / don’t know |
| Delabole - Cornwall |
| DTI DTI |
| 1992/93 1990 |
| 85% 17% |
| 4% 32% |
| 11% 51% |
| Bryn Titli - Powys |
| RBA |
| 1993 |
| 75% |
| 10% |
| 15% |
| Llandinam - Powys |
| BBC |
| 1994 |
| 76% |
| 17% |
| 7% |
| Taff Ely - Rhondda |
| BBC |
| 1994 |
| 74% |
| 9% |
| 17% |
| Rhyd y Groes - Anglesey |
| BBC |
| 1994 |
| 61% |
| 32% |
| 7% |
| Kirkby Moor - Cumbria |
| RBA |
| 1994 |
| 82% |
| 9% |
| 9% |
| Cemmaes - Powys |
| DTI |
| 1992/93 |
| 86% |
| 1% |
| 13% |
| Taff Ely - Glamorgan |
| RBA |
| 1997 |
| 63% |
| 4% |
| 32% |
| Novar Estate - Highlands |
| RBA |
| 1998 |
| 70% |
| 12% |
| N/A |
| Llandinam - Powys |
| CCW |
| 1992/93 |
| 83% |
| 14% |
| 3% |
| Llangwryfon - Dyfed |
| CCW |
| 1992/93 |
| 78% |
| 14% |
| 8% |
| Rhyd-y-Groes - Anglesey |
| CCW |
| 1992/93 |
| 74% |
| 9% |
| 17% |
Most recently, the Scottish Executive’s Central Research Unit carried out research on public attitudes to 4 wind farms in Scotland, namely Beinn Glas in Argyle, Hagshaw Hill in South Lanarkshire, Novar in Highland and Windy Standard in Dumfries and Galloway. The main findings of this survey are summarised as follows:
Respondents were generally positive about wind farms. Those who live nearest a wind farm are more likely to provide positive responses when asked about the wind farm than those in the other zones. For example, while 67% overall reported that there was something they liked about the wind farm, this proportion increases to 73% of those living in the high proximity zone (up to 5km from a wind farm).
The proportion of respondents who had anticipated problems prior to the development (40%) was far higher than the proportion who actually experienced problems after the development (9%). Actual noise caused by the turbines or the visual impact of the wind farm did not feature as issues for the large majority of respondents.
Only 2% of respondents said that they disliked the wind farm because it was noisy, and although 12% of respondents had expected to experience a problem with noise, only 1% had actually experienced a problem.
Although respondents were generally positive about the farms and most would not be concerned about future development, the majority think that wind farms should be located in uninhabited areas and high on hills.
It should be noted that in many cases, environmental assessments identified potential significant effects on landscape quality and amenity in the vicinity of these windfarms. Despite this, Table 5.1 and the CRU research clearly show that, once built and operational, significant effects are not necessarily considered to be unacceptable to the large majority of members of the public.

|
|